ketzy – There are posters that come across as very haughty. When you prove that they are full of hot air they resort to put-downs.
I wouldn’t have put so much time into this, but I know when posters quote resources and have the attitude that they are 100% right they will influence others.
In this case I have heard of this Chumra but to quote Achronim and say the Halacha is like these Achronim and the Achronim hold this Chumra is Halacha is the most dangerous thing. This is why the Torah said “Lo (Baal) Tosif”.
IMHO changing Halacha is like Kefira that’s why CHAZAL say “Megalah Ponim B’Torah Shelo K’halacha Ain Lo Chelek L’olam Haboh”.
It’s very sad when s/o openly lies to push his way after putting me down – from above:
“I don’t know your level of yedios, but with respect I ask, have you heard of the Biur Halacha (it is authored by the Mishna Brura and published in that sefer)? The M.B. in his Biur Halacha paskens like that R’ Akiva Eiger (although he adds some unrelated qualification).”
Did he really think I wouldn’t look it up? My only Limud Zecus for him is he heard this from s/o else but didn’t look it up himself.
Because if he knew what the BH wrote and changed it for his Nefarious purposes – this is a Mazid. Misquoting Halacha on purpose is Playing with Fire!