Reply To: Question on sugya in Niddah 5a

Home Forums Bais Medrash Question on sugya in Niddah 5a Reply To: Question on sugya in Niddah 5a

#915358
HaLeiVi
Participant

The first Tosafos on Daf 5 points this out. In the second definition of the Machlokes — that they argue about Shaas Vestan — the Braisa can only be Reb Dosa, since it says that Shelo Beshaas Vesta she is Tamei Me’es La’es. Obviously, Beshaas Vesta we say Dayan Shaatan, which is Reb Dosa.

When the Gemara says that the Braisa is Kulei Alma, it is only in regards to Shelo Beshaas Vesta being Tamei Me’es La’es, says Tosafos.