@DY Actually after looking at the old thread it seems even clearer that Rav Belsky holds its maasig gvul (and possibly Rav Moshe too from the way he was quoted there). this is the link that was cited there although i am not sure if it will be posted http://torah.org/learning/honesty/class64.html. I am not familiar with the specific language of what Rav Elyashiv said and I never had the privilege to speak with him so I can’t disagree with you on that. If you have a direct quote from him I would love to see it. Also from the famous “Aderet Rental Clause” it would appear that they do intend for you to buy 2 copies. I am aware that it is not the best proof which is why I brought the other 2.
Menu