Reply To: ??? ???? ?? ????

yekke2 –

a) The asei is also shvach, because the same she’aile can stop the chiyuv to be megaleach?

The chiyuv to be megaleyach that we are talking about is a separate chiyuv, that of metzora. This cannot be undone with she’eila.

b) Even after the chiluk, if sof kol sof you have a way out that you are not forced to be oiver on the lo sasei to be mekayem the asei, then you would have to do that, which in this case means being shoel on the nezirus?

That’s a good question, but not on me. At the end of the day the fact of the matter is we do say asei docheh lo sa’asei here. The Gemara is simply pointing out that you can’t learn from here to other places, because here the lav is not as strong as other places. All we are taynehing is that this Gemara’s point has no bearing on cases where the lav is strong and the asei is weaker than other places.

It’s more cheshbon than lomdus, but doik and it’s pashut.