GAW –
So you have excluded all those who call fellow Yidden “Reshaim Gemurim” just because the (supposed Reshaim) no longer want to pay for them (the namecallers) to sit and learn (and/or want their children to have a better chance of survival) (certainly not Middos Tovos)?
Middos Tovos is a requirement from the Gemoro, not my own definition. As is well known Chazal call a person who does not have middos tovos to go with his learning a “chamor noseh seforim”.
And you have included those who would create a Rabbah.
How have I done that? Creating a ‘Rabbah’ is outside of even the stretchiest of stretched bounds of Halacha so how is someone who believes in doing so included?
No idea who Rabbi Saul Lieberman was.