Reply To: Must a Goy keep Shabbos?

Sam2 – I have heard a Binyan Tzion that a goy’s ????? is not ????? ????? but rather from physical labour, and therefore a goy who shlepps a sofa around his living room will not be ???? on ??? ????. However, a Yid who does physical labour but is not ???? on one of the 39 ?????? is not ???? ???.

So, I guess, according to that, a ??? MUST do physical labour of some sort, but MUST NOT be ???? ??? as we call it.

This is quite a big chiddush! If a goy asks you what he can do on shabbos, what would you say?