I never said that this was my position, or that this was my only position. My premise is based on arguing with pro gay marriage activists. You cannot go up to someone who believes that gay people have civil rights and should be able to get married just like anybody else and say “you can’t get married because God said so”. It isn’t going to fly and it’s only going to give us a bad name.
Now, yes, man/dog and man/man relationships are both perverse. But they are perverse in different ways, and there is a way to make a distinction between them using the American justice system. If you ignore that distinction, you show your ignorance and immediately lose all credibility with a gay rights activist.
It’s not about being right. It’s about winning.