Reply To: The Draft and Mattos-Masei

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee The Draft and Mattos-Masei Reply To: The Draft and Mattos-Masei

#967009
HaKatan
Participant

Thank you, toi.

“truthsharer”:

Perhaps your screen name would be better written “wishsharer”.

Are you calling Rav Chaim Brisker a liar?

That wouldn’t be a very bright thing to do since, aside for the obvious reasons, he lived there and then and knew from personal experience both pre-1948 and post-1948 what Zionism was and is.

Historical fact and current events happenings are not subject to your or anyone else’s denials. Zionism was and is what it was and is: shmad. This is still true even though their methods of shmad have changed since Yaldei Tehran, etc. Zionism was and is shmad.

If you’re better informed than Rav Chaim Brisker (pre-1948 and post-1948) and Rav Elchonon (pre-1948 only, HY”D), who lived there and then, please provide a comparable source that disagrees with them and with, lihavdil, the Zionists themselves. This is not a secret.

In other words, if you claim Rav Chaim’s words (and history and current events) are not true, then please provide a reliable same-level source who contradicts those facts.