Reply To: Popa's eggs mishmar shaila

My answer, and DY’s answer, is this:

If you see where it is, and then it gets mixed in, then you know that there is one rishon which holds it is assur, so since we are machmir like both the raah and the rif/rambam, we are machmir and it is assur.

But if you didn’t see where it was and then it gets mixed in–then both the rif/rambam and the raah themselves–would hold it is muttar. Because if you brought it to the raah, he would look at it, say it is a safek issur and in a taaruvos so it is muttur. And if you brought it to the rif or rambam, they would say the same. So yes, we are machmir like both shittos–but we are machmir m’safek like both shittos, not that we think that both are concurrently correct. So if according to both shittos it would be muttar, we also say it is muttar.

What you think?