I worked in a very black hat yeshiva as a social studies teacher.
A kid, kind of OTD, asked me if I thought Taylor Swift was attractive. My answer was that I’m not into shidduchim with shiksas, nor women that are hipsters. Needless to say, his mother got a call home that night, and so did the rosh yeshiva.
Carly Simon, Carole King, James Taylor, etc. are among my favorites.
And for the person above using the “No True Scotsman” fallacy in reference to this thread: there are many who would say that a person who uses the internet is “no true frumme yid.” Where does the buck stop?