Reply To: Eggs�Davar Shebiminyan

Home Forums Bais Medrash Eggs�Davar Shebiminyan Reply To: Eggs�Davar Shebiminyan

#970128
yitayningwut
Participant

I have not thought enough about this, but I have an initial thought.

Eggs are not a davar shebeminyan here in the USA.

Now you say, but of course they are! They are sold by the dozen!

Well I say that’s exactly why they are not. Davar shebeminyan is when they are sold by individual count, hence each one is a davar chashuv, but when they are never sold individually and only in dozens then it is the entire package of a dozen which is a davar shebeminyan; the individual eggs are nothings!

Again, I have not thought about this much, and I don’t remember the sugya well. It just occurred to me.