“There are certain piskei din that, while having halacha status, deserve to be questioned.”
When people “question” certain piskei din the way they “question” halachos in shulchan aruch perhaps i would be open to a discussion on this topic, until then, you are correct, this is not the proper forum for such a discussion. I do think that overall, respect for Rabbonim and Batei Din are at an all time low. that is the greatest tragedy of our generation and probably the source for many of our ills. We think we are smarter than the halacha and look where it has led us. Every time you turn around someone is talking about a new crisis.