DaMoshe, if they reject Weiss’ geirus, they should have inserted into their statement, “but had they asked us, we would have told them to reject his geirus”.
If there are people doing invalid geirus in the US, calling themselves Orthodox even though they’re apikirsom, and they’re RCA members, it would be irresponsible to not question the definition of “Orthodox” in the US.
ZD’s right about there being politics. The RCA is fearful of having all of their members’ geirus questioned, because they’re not selective enough about who they allow as members, so they’re getting all defensive. They should not be playing politics with geirus.