_______ makes the best pizza

Home Coffeeroom Decaffeinated Coffee _______ makes the best pizza

Tagged: 

Viewing 78 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
  • #596249

    TheGoq
    Participant

    __________ makes the best pizza in ____________ neighborhood. The reason it is so good is because of _________________.

    Let the debate begin!

  • #1016488

    yogibooboo
    Member

    shula’s….five towns…the workers there are such NICE and WARM people. its always fresh and always delicious! i got sick of the rest of the places in the five towns. another place has doughy pizza which is not what pizza is. another one looked moldy every time we went in and another place had roaches crawling everywhere!

  • #1016489

    mewho
    Member

    i make the best pizza in my neighborhood. the reason it is so good is because of the fresh ingredients and cleanliness of my kitchen,

  • #1016490

    mytake
    Member

    I make the best pizza in Rockland County. The reason it is so good is cuz my Bubby gave me her secret recipe.

  • #1016491

    always here
    Participant

    the old Netanya on Ave. J in Flatbush: the best tasting sauce (to me… not spicy), & nice ‘n cheesy. but now there’s new ownership & I have yet to find a pizza place that has the sauce just how I like it.

  • #1016492

    jofes
    Member

    Pizza Time makes the best pizza in Flatbush. The reason it is so good is because of The Service & The Taste.

  • #1016493

    HAKOL TOV
    Member

    j2!

  • #1016494

    Ofcourse
    Member

    Amnon’s makes the best pizza in BP. The reason it is so good is because of the huge turnover, so its always fresh, and the boss’ watchful eye. Amnon was going to sell and retire, but hes still at it, amush! Nice guy!

  • #1016495

    adorable
    Participant

    Pita land in Monsey- thick crust, very moist pizza, nice ppl working there and very friendly place in general! where are all the monseyers sticking up for their place?!?!?!?

  • #1016496

    bennys makes the best pizza on avenue m cuz its taste like its straight from italy!

  • #1016497

    cherrybim
    Participant

    “The old Netanya on Ave. J”

    I agree; and if the new owners would have kept the Netanya recipe, they’d still be in business.

  • #1016498

    GumBall
    Member

    J2,Mendelshons,Pizza Time,…

  • #1016499

    HLM
    Member

    AMNONS!!!!!!!!!!!! FOR SURE!!!!!!!! As soon as I take a bite my mouth begins to water…. MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • #1016500

    Feif Un
    Member

    The old Netanya was the best. I remember when I was in yeshiva we went there on Fridays to get their special – 2 slices, fries, and a soda for $3.25. And don’t forget the plate of pickle chips they’d throw in!

  • #1016501

    am yisrael chai
    Participant

    Netanya’s was my family’s meeting place for years…loved the pizza…before my family moved…to Netanya

  • #1016502

    happiest
    Member

    The pizza store on the Lower East Side is heavenly!! Like delicious!!!

  • #1016503

    apushatayid
    Participant

    The place that baked a roach into the pizza and then offered me another slice when I pointed it out.

  • #1016504

    erm_saywhat
    Member

    The best Pizza in Lower East Side is … (drumroll… pu-leez):

    Shalom Chai Pizza

  • #1016505

    erm_saywhat
    Member

    The best Pizza in the Five Towns is David’s (on Central). He’s so polite and takes a genuine interest.

  • #1016506

    pumper
    Member

    I’m so surprised no one said it:

    Rosa’s in the Empire State Building has amazing pizza!

    There is tons of variety- including the popular french fry slice!

  • #1016507

    goldielox
    Member

    Mendlesons in boro park ‘cuz of the sauce

  • #1016508

    smartcookie
    Member

    A pushita yid- your CRAZY!!! I’m so disgusted!! And I was planning to have pizza for supper tomorrow!

  • #1016509

    gefen
    Member

    Go happiest and erm_saywhat! hurray for the lower east side. i was born there and grew up there! i now live elsewhere but the LES will always be a part of who i am.

    anyway – there’s a pizza place in teaneck nj (at least i think it’s still there). It’s called Pizza Crave. YUMMMMM! not only the best pizza, but all their food is great. the place is nice and clean. every time we took a trip to ny – we made sure to stop at pizza crave (we have friends in teaneck – that’s how we found out about the place). We haven’t been back to ny in a while. I miss it.

  • #1016510

    gefen
    Member

    mendelsons in bp is also good.

  • #1016511

    eclipse
    Member

    Bon Appetit pizza is very good and very courteous.

  • #1016512

    ontheball
    Member

    Pizza Time on Ave J. Best sauce & crust by far!

  • #1016513

    I have lots of relatives on the Lower East Side and agree that Shalom Chai has the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. We go there every time we visit my aunt and uncle.

  • #1016514

    Feif Un
    Member

    apushatayid: I once had that when I was younger! We had a pie delivered, and there was a roach in it. My brother called them up and told them. They said they’d send over another pie ASAP. My brother said, “Why, so we can get another roach?”

    On a side note, if you see a roach was baked into a pizza, I wonder if the oven needs to be kashered?

  • #1016515

    ha ha ha ha
    Member

    feif- what kashered when you have a fly fall into a pot of soup that pot needs to be kashered??!!?? and if it falls into a cup of hot tea the cup has to be kashered???

  • #1016516

    bygirl93
    Member

    pizza pious- five towns- best pizza, plain fries, garlic knots, and ZEPPOLIES!!!!

    Amnons- in BP- hands down-

    and mendel’s pizza has awesome fries!!!

  • #1016517

    bygirl93
    Member

    reading this thread is making me hungry for…… pizza!!! wat else? Hold the roaches!!!

  • #1016518

    One things is for-sure: the letter-gradings show a lot. Now when stores don’t have good grades I don’t eat there with my friends or family…People really don’t know what filth they’re eating.

    On another note, pizza time rocks!

  • #1016519

    brotherofurs
    Participant

    pizza Time in FLatbush on ave J cause i love their “Grandma slices”- (square with cheese then sauc-YUMMMMMMMY)

  • #1016520

    justsmile613
    Member

    What about out of Brooklyn? or out of new york?

  • #1016521

    deiyezooger
    Member

    “Pita land in Monsey- thick crust, very moist pizza, nice ppl working there and very friendly place in general! where are all the monseyers sticking up for their place?!?!?!?”

    Monseyers are not exectly the bigest pizza eaters to begin with, but for that rare ocasion its Chai pizza.

  • #1016522

    golden mom
    Member

    The grades don’t mean anything I haven’t seen anybody get anything but an A

  • #1016523

    walton157
    Member

    I miss Netanya a lot. They really had the best pizza and the couple who owned the shop are very nice!!!

  • #1016524

    walton157
    Member

    @Feif Un: Re: Roaches in the pizza: EWWWWW!!!

  • #1016525

    Golden Mom: oh yes, the grades DO mean a lot. Maybe you haven’t been around New York/Brooklyn to see them! Many stores did get B’s or C’s(gasp!)And I could predict most of the grades..u could tell how dirty a store is.

  • #1016526

    mommas3
    Member

    NO GOOD PIZZA IN TORONTO 🙁

    but in brooklyn, Bon Apetit on Coney Island between L and M has amazing pizza, and very good specials! yum!

  • #1016527

    shkoyach
    Member

    Lakewood Kosher Pizza on Clifton and 1st makes one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted!

    Also, the old kol tuv pizza at the capitol… I forgot the new name but new owners and new recipe make pretty good pizza too! Tho the truth is I must say that I like all the pizzas I have tasted in the Lkwd places!

    oh… I am so hungry!!!!!!!!

  • #1016528

    World Saver
    Member

    Pizza Mayven in LA has by far the best Pizza anywhere in the world. (Just make sure you get a fresh slice).

  • #1016529

    Health
    Participant

    shkoyach – I haven’t tasted a decent pizza here yet. If you want good pizza – go to Deal.

  • #1016530

    Di Fara, Midwood.

    Too bad it isn’t Kosher. But I do have a real Yetzer Hara when I am in Brooklyn to try a slice.

  • #1016531

    yogibooboo
    Member

    pumper-we went there once and the second time my husband went there him and some other guys got food poisoning from there! we stay far away!

    erm_saywhat-if the hangout wasnt as it was more people would be there. I HATE going there on Sat nights eventhough i dont get there anymore, but there was a kid walking around without a shirt and I told the owner that I wasnt gonna come in anymore.

  • #1016532

    pumper
    Member

    yogi-

    too bad you had a bad experience there. (Guess that can happen almost anywhere) you are just missing out on some seriously good pizza! Grandma slices are the best!

  • #1016533

    Health
    Participant

    “Rosa’s in the Empire State Building has amazing pizza!”

    Where is this store (entrance)? I’ve been by the ESB many, many times and I’ve never seen it. All I know about is the pizza shop across the street on 33rd closer to 6th Ave.

  • #1016535

    hanib
    Participant

    out of town: tov pizza and mama leah’s (cheeseless, with vegetables) – both are delicious!

  • #1016536

    pumper
    Member

    Health-

    It is closest to the entrance on 33rd. When you go in, make a left and there it is! (It recently turned kosher, so you may not have noticed it before.)

  • #1016537

    Hey pumper, I’m always looking for new restaurants/pizza stores in the city..Do u know exactly where that place is? Do u know the hechsher too?

  • #1016538

    goody613
    Member

    Pizza King! best kept secret in brooklyn

  • #1016539

    pumper
    Member

    over a cup of coffee-

    It is a great pizza shop called Rosa’s located inside the Empire State Building. Go in by the 33rd street entrance, make the first left, and there it is!

    I am pretty sure that the hechsher is OU-Cholov Yisroel

    If you check it out I am sure that you will love it!

  • #1016541

    TheGoq
    Participant

    I know its cruel to bump a pizza thread on a taanis but here we go!

  • #1016542

    Sbarro in Malcha!!! i hope everyone has an easy fast, i broke mine in the old city with my cousins.

  • #1016543

    Fialkoffs from Monticello!!! The Pizza there is Amazing! And its a family owned for years!

  • #1016544

    TheGoq
    Participant

    “i broke mine in the old city with my cousins.”

    how did they taste?

  • #1016545

    lol. I meant I ate WITH them.

  • #1016546

    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    Popa’s because of the crust.

  • #1016547

    mommamia22
    Member

    Bravo pizza in NYC.

    Seriously crowded, but the pizza is DELICIOUS!

  • #1016548

    ari-free
    Participant

    Solo is turning into a pizza restaurant. F Fabricant from NY Times wrote:

    But wait, there’s more. Adriani is also famous for his montanara pizza. They first fry the dough, put toppings and bake it a 1000 degree wood fired oven. That’s similar to the oven we use to bake shmura matzo.

  • #1016549

    rebdoniel
    Member

    Rosa’s is no longer kosher. Bravo Pizza went kosher and is fantastic.

    Pastene brand makes San Marzano tomatoes with the OK hechsher. I think ShopRite carries their items which are really good.

    Pastene tonno, Italian tuna in olive oil, is far superior to American tuna, and is OU.

  • #1016550

    Eli’s Bagels and Pizza Garden in Monsey! They serve brick-oven Pizza with a nice thin crust. and they have a GREAT counter worker.

  • #1016551

    15th Ave Pizza! AKA Naim’s.

  • #1016552

    ilikecheese
    Member

    duh bravos forsure best kosger pizza on earth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • #1016553

    rebdoniel
    Member

    Anyone ever tried Posh Tomato? It looks nouveau.

  • #1016554

    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    I was kind of underwhelmed by Bravo. The next time I just went back to J2.

  • #1016555

    YW Moderator-29
    Moderator

    Badum bum(p)

  • #1016556

    I didn’t know you played the drums (Badum bum(p))

  • #1016557

    YW Moderator-29
    Moderator

    It was a mod requirement

  • #1016558

    OURtorah
    Member

    29 ur the bomb!!!!!!

  • #1016559

    I find my mums pizza to be the best (it’s flieshig though, no cheese)

  • #1016560

    oyyoyyoy
    Member

    iz nisht ken pizza

  • #1016561

    I beg to differ. If you check up the holy googler rebbe it seems there is a tzad to say that they fall into the geder of pizza. (and lfi other poskim, such as the egel hazahav and the baal otzitz nokev,”Lahamagine” has a din pizza. although I’d like a sfardi to verify this for me)

  • #1016562

    Mercaz Hapizza in Beit Shemesh! SO yummy and chewy.

  • #1016563

    notasheep
    Member

    If you’ve ever been to Italy, the real Italian pizza is the best. Other than that, my sister in law’s is amazing.

  • #1016564

    DaasYochid
    Participant

    Notasheep, is popa your sister-in-law?

  • #1016565

    notasheep
    Member

    Absolutely not! In case you didn’t realise from old posts of mine, I live in Gateshead, and my sister in law also does.

  • #1016567

    popa_bar_abba
    Participant

    I’m making a new recipe soon.

  • #1016568

    DaasYochid
    Participant

    What’s wrong with the old one?

Viewing 78 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to RSS Feed For This Article