Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › To add to the list of YU’s sins › Reply To: To add to the list of YU’s sins
>>Smerel, I gave clear mareh mekomos in my first post. Look them up. Goyim who learn Torah are chayav misah.
Depends on the aspect of Torah. The Gemora Bava Kama 38A says
???????? ???????????? ????? ???????? ?????????? ???????
???????? ??????? ????????? ?????? ?????? ???????? ????? ??????? ????? ??????
Based on that the Rishoniim distinguish on what he is learning
That is why it is a complicated sugya and without maarhe mokomos down to achronim in relation o this specie situation you are just hocking.
>>>Re, B�b 15b, it�s not saying that goyim should learn it, it�s saying that nevuah was said about them.
You are badly misquoting the Gemora. If the Gemoroa meant “about” it would say “al” or “Odos” If as you understand it to e saying that ???????? ????????? ???????????? ?????????? ???????? means that seven Neviem were sent about (but not for) non-Jews and that ????? � ??????? ???????????????? ??????????
???????? means that Sefer Iyov was primally written about (but not for) non-Jews then you would have to say that people like Bilaam said his main nevuah about non-Jews (to who?) and that Sefer Iyov which does not discuss explicitly discuss non-Jews at all was primarily written about them. .