Reply To: Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch and the IDF (Israeli Army)

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch and the IDF (Israeli Army) Reply To: Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch and the IDF (Israeli Army)

#2432851
yankel berel
Participant

1] sh’ a OC 329 mandates yotsin aleihen bikli zayin ,meaning

you go and fight them with weapons.

2] sh’a YD 156 clearly states that any other avera besides the three hamurot , meaning

all other averot [including supposed oaths] yaavor veal yehareig , because pikuach nefesh is doche all issurim , meaning

you go, fight and save lives

not like maharal often quoted by satmar

not like this HUGE HIDDUSH that all of the millions of innocent people in EY ,are required to die rather than defend themselves

3] supposed issur of oaths are never mentioned anywhere in sh’a , not in OC , not in YD , not in EH, and not in CM., meaning

there is no issur to fight in the first place

Three clear proofs that sh’a plus rama plus all nosei keilim rule not like maharal [which is anyway mentioned in a non halachik sefer]

in what other area in the torah do we rule like a non halachik sefer against the established pillars of halacha ?

why is this area any different to any other ?

this is not a hashkafic question – this is a clear halachik question in hilchot pikuach nefesh

.