Reply To: Old Yishuv Residents: Pre-1948 vs. Pre-1880

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Old Yishuv Residents: Pre-1948 vs. Pre-1880 Reply To: Old Yishuv Residents: Pre-1948 vs. Pre-1880

#2454139

yankel on mitzrim – exactly, you can have hakarat hatov and still have other restrictions. You can have appreciation to what Zionists did without becoming a chosid of Ben Gurion.

But your underlying premise seems to be that zionists brought damage to yirat shamayim. I question that. I think most of early non-religious zionist followers were either non-religious already or on the way of becoming such. In other words, without zionists, most of those Jews would have been communists, culturalists, converts, bundists, etc. That was the reality of the times. And while zionist propaganda sounded awful to religious ears at the time, in political reality, they guided these multitudes to be savevd both physically and spiritually.