Reply To: Why Didn't Hilni Sit in a Kosher Sukkah?

Home Forums Bais Medrash Daf Yomi Sukkah Why Didn't Hilni Sit in a Kosher Sukkah? Reply To: Why Didn't Hilni Sit in a Kosher Sukkah?

#1002437
HaLeiVi
Participant

Don’t you see that the Gemara doesn’t assume she knew better? Rebbe Yehuda mentions the fact that the Chachamim didn’t correct her, which means that it is assumed that she didn’t know on her own. She was not Bruria and we are not learning from her.