Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › Hakaras Hatov for Israeli Soldiers (IDF) › Reply To: Hakaras Hatov for Israeli Soldiers (IDF)
Just Emes:
As to the rest of your post:
Your point 1 is irrelevant; the indisputable fact is that Israel was not founded biShalom.
Your point 2 is simply a fantasy and propaganda, as I explained numerous times. The Zionists themselves admit they took a foolish and tremendous gamble with Jewish lives, and (in 1948 alone) did sacrifice thousands of Jewish lives, for this idol.
Regarding your alleged Halacha, just because you make up a story about Rav Moshe, that doesn’t change the halacha berura. Pikuach nefesh is not nidche for Zionist idolatry. Founding the State of Israel undeniably and needlessly cost Jewish lives. (The oaths also apply.)
Case definitely closed, as you write.
As written above, Zionism was and is A”Z according to multiple gedolim, and founding the State was also clearly assur for additional reasons as described above.
Again, the Zionists have no answers.