But people claiming that aren’t out for blood.
No, for many it’s an understandable emotional issue (we’ve had threads about it, and I’ve dealt with their tayna IRL as well), but this solution, as well as the sheirut leumi idea, shows the illogicality of it.
I don’t think such a program will take off as the standard. You’re asking bochurim to decide at age 18(?) that they will never develop the hasmadah to learn full time. That’s too young, IMO.