Reply To: Celebrating good caused by bad

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Celebrating good caused by bad Reply To: Celebrating good caused by bad

#1018215
HaKatan
Participant

Sam2:

There is nothing to admit. History is plain that there simply was no neis. One is entitled to one’s own opinion, not one’s own facts.

But “no neis” does not contradict, CH”V, neither Hashem’s full control of the world nor, for that matter, bechira chafshis.

The Zionists prefer to instead claim non-existent miracles that, even if it were true, that therefore there should be a new Yom Tov in Klal Yisrael for the first time since the establishment of the only holiday established after Tanach, Chanukah (disregarding, for this purpose, other Zionist holidays), especially given the cost in lives, that the Zionists were the ones who lost it in the first place, etc.

I don’t see the irony of consistent belief in the Torah and only the Torah

edited