Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

Home Forums Controversial Topics How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

#1027940
Health
Participant

Sam2 -“PBA: If it can be proven (and I’m not saying it has, but if it can) that requiring by mouth is a Sakanas Nefashos for these babies, then wouldn’t you agree that we don’t have to accord any respect to those who do it? That we should stop them from putting their children in danger?”

What would have to be proven that it’s a Sofek, but right now I think the criteria of the proof would be at Sfak Sfaka. I don’t think it’s Ossur to do MBP, but why not work out a solution where No babies or almost No babies will get sick? And I posted the solution above.