Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah › Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah
Small and significantly limited is still too much in the view of many, myself (and many Gedolim) included.
That is not an intelligent view. You cannot simply say “any danger is too much”, as I very finely argued above ad nauseum.
And no gadol ever has objected on these grounds. The gedolim who say not to do it are the ones who hold it isn’t halacha anyway. No gadol is telling the poskim who hold it is halacha that they should be mevatel daas to them for this reason.
And no, the rasha tendler is not a gadol. Blast that, he’s not even ???? ?????. (Hmm, can you be a gadol but not b’chlal amisecha? Was Acher a gadol? How about Yochanan Kohein Gadol? Is Kohen Gadol the same as Gadol?)