Reply To: Source in Torah and/or Gemara for Kapparos

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Source in Torah and/or Gemara for Kapparos Reply To: Source in Torah and/or Gemara for Kapparos

#1034380
Sam2
Participant

Lior: Trust me, R’ Chaim knows many Rishonim and Achronim hold it’s Assur. My question was one of societal curiosity, not saying it should be stopped.

HaLeiVi: I have nothing against the Arizal, even if I’m rarely Makpid for things which the writings of his Talmidim are the Makor (and wasn’t accepted by a large number of later Poskim). He was a unique person who is a different branch of the Mesorah.

And Chareidi society tries to be smarter than their Rebbeim with every new Chumra introduced. I’m just curious why this is different.