GG Yekke – point!
HaLeiVi:
Oomis, since they are Mechuyav to fast they obviously must eat, but the question here is about the specific mitzva of eating which is different from the need to eat Erev Tisha B'av. This is a Mitzva which happens to coincide with the need.
Now, let’s look back at what Oomis wrote:
If women have a chiyuv to FAST, then they should also have a chiyuv to EAT. I don’t see a chiluk here. (emphasis added)
HaLeiVi again:
I would say that if it is an Asmachta that would be reason tip apply to Nashim as well. Derabanans don't necessarily have the exemption of Zman Grama, at least not when the reasoning applies to Nashim as well.
Rabi Akiva Eiger:
[????’ ??”? ?”? ?????? ????? ?????? ?? ?? ???? ??? ????? ????? ?????? ??’ ???? ????? ?? ??? ?????? ????? ???? ?? ??? ??? ??? ????]
Rule of 3:
And Succah is for ?????? ??????. does that make it a Chiyuv for Nashim? ?? ?? ??? ????? ???.
If that’s in response to this
1)Since you cant do vesomachtoh v’chagecho on yom kippur we do it on ever yom kippur. […]
the ksav sofer says l’fi r’yonas reasons, women are chiyuv.
you’re arguing with the K’sav Sofer.
Screwdriver:
The punishment can be mine or Popa’s. I could be saying that I came on for a specific reason, but one thing led to another, or that I had a valid reason to be on now, as opposed to him. Only one of these really makes sense, though – can you figure it out?