Sam: How do you respond to Dash’s sentence immediately prior to the one you quoted? Namely, “You can’t Pasken that someone is not jewish simply because of the ramifications that would occur if they were jewish.
The Karities are more in this area, their Gittim have not be ruled correctly, but I think the Psak has been their Kiddusim have not been correct either so its ok to marry a Karite and they are Kosher jews