yekke: Wrong. It’s very clear. The fact that we can find Rishonim that held that the child needs Geirus does not change the fact that we Pasken, with no doubt about it whatsoever, that the mother being Jewish makes you Jewish. The other Shittos are not even ever used as a Snif L’hakel L’hatir Augnos. There is no controversy. There was a Machlokes Rishonim which has been clearly Paskened. End of discussion.
Menu