Reply To: Techeiles 🔵❎🐌☑️🐟

“There are two reasons that you can dismiss the evidence: 1- it doesn’t meet the required standard; 2- there is no standard [good enough].”

If you want to claim that it doesn’t meet a standard, you have to set a standard. Besides for the fact that we seem to have a raya muchrachas that the murex trunculus was the chilazon used in the times of chazal.

And as mentioned before, if you want to hold like The Rav that there is no standard, then you have to apply that to everything not just Techeiles. Besides for the fact that that whole shitta is a daas yochid ad meod and does not seem to have any mekor in shas and poskim.