Reply To: Beshert

Home Forums Shidduchim Beshert Reply To: Beshert

#1058763
yitayningwut
Participant

bachur24-

You haven’t responded as to whether you are well versed in the Rambam’s works. I assume you are not. Take a look at the last of the 8 Perakim, you will find that the Rambam understands ??? ???? ???? ??? ????? ???? to mean that every action that is a lav or an aseh is fully within one’s bechirah. That is, it isn’t that Hashem gives us bechirah, or an illusion of it, in instances in which there are mitzvos. It’s the other way around, there are certain things which Hashem originally gave man full autonomy over, and those are all of his actions, and because that is so, he gave us mitzvos in those areas. Look it up and think about it.