Reply To: Picking and Choosing Kulas

Home Forums Bais Medrash Minhagim Picking and Choosing Kulas Reply To: Picking and Choosing Kulas

#1067422
gavra_at_work
Participant

Like mdd said HERE a couple of days ago, you can be matir 3/4 of Shulchan Aruch like this. And as mdd correctly pointed out, by posting these kulas as if they are accepted psak you are confusing part of the olam here with the shvere minority shittas that we do not pasken like. And you may be causing people to be nichshol.

Who is “we”?

Rav Moshe is Mattir “Cholov HaCompanies”. “We” (as in Klal Yisroel in America) is Noheg like Rav Moshe.

The Bach (and possibly the Rema) is Mattir Chadash in Chul. “We” Pasken like the Bach.

When you tell me who the “we” is that does not pasken like “minority shittos” (your term), then “we” can discuss. “We” might also be Satmer Chassidim, and “we” Pasken that women must shave their heads. Are those who argue “minority shittos”? Perhaps Rav Yoel (the Satmer Rov) is the majority by definition!