Reply To: 'Halachic Dinner" – What do you think about it?

phil: “you are not a Rav or a Manhig and have no right whatsoever to criticize others…..”

Seems like you are criticizing me and giving me tochacha for commenting on a public event. Are you a rov? Are you a manhig to criticize and judge me? You dont need to be.

I have every right to say what I said, and there is no halachic difference between a person who is a rov and one who is not- as halachic smicha no longer exists. and even if it did, it would have no bearing on this conversation. Seems like you are trying to find some way of silencing others that you disagree with.