Reply To: What is mandated in NY for private schooling

You can’t expect a parent to pay THEIR WHOLE ANNUAL INCOME for tuition, even if you technically believe they should do just that.

Why not? You make them you pay for them. Chazal (Kesubos 49b) certainly expected someone to be responsible to pay for their children, including their chinuch.

But they probably sing songs about Chanukah and not about… And because they do only special Ed they excel more at it versus a public school that also does special Ed.

Please delete this point. If this got out then KJ would be sued (and lose!) for teaching religion in public school. In reality, they are probably careful not to sing songs about either the Roteh Rebbe or Judah Maccabee.