Lets peek into an imaginary bes knesses. Two are learning, one is preoccupied (spaced out to those under 50) two are talking and poof, there is no minyan for the CH. The shatz, paying full attention to his chazara, does not realize he has made 19 brochos levatala, in EY, add a bracha levatala for the cohanim. In my humble nothingnes’s opinion, the shatz not saying modim out loud, or a shatz that is too fast for the theoretical am ha’aretz to follow, this is also not k’takonas chazal, and all brocho levatolo. I have similar issues with the singing in unison with the shatz on yomim tovim, or with the shatz reading piyyutim silently. I have a very lonely existence with my shittos.
Menu