Reply To: Theological Conundrum (read at your own risk)

But what’s wrong with doing something wrong?

Also, “[e]verybody has an innate sense of moral sense” is a bit of an oversimplification. Avram’s terrorist thinks that it is right to kill people. Now you might say that the terrorist’s indoctrinated beliefs are subverting his innate moral sense. But you could say the same thing about akeidas Yitzchak. So then you will have to say that God can command whatever he wants, even if it is against inherent morality. And then DaasYochid might tell you that you just said kefira.