Reply To: Cholov Yisroel and Gan Eden

Matan1: If your response to my above question to you is that if one’s Rov holds CS is permissible to consume then he receives no additional schar or olam haba if he is machmir to only consume CY, then my follow-up to you is three-fold:

a. If there’s no obligation to say Tehilim why does one receive schar for saying it but no schar for only eating CY?

b. Did the person in this aforementioned scenario (with the CS-permitting rov) who strictly only consumed CY, waste his life avoiding CS that he could have and should have enjoyed, and received no spiritual benefit for avoiding?

c. Why did Rav Moshe say that a baal nefesh shouldn’t eat CS? Putting aside the question of who or what a baal nefesh is, did Rav Moshe hold that a baal nefesh would receive schar for avoiding CS even though CS is permissible?