Reply To: DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction?

Home Forums YWN Main Site & Coffee Room Issues DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction? Reply To: DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction?

#1112044
HaKatan
Participant

simcha613 and others:

There simply is no eilu viEilu here, unfortunately.

The problem, is, however, with “Zionists”, including “Religious Zionists” who have no mesorah for their idolatry and heresy.

Going back to the oaths (on which the Satmar Rav wrote an entire sefer), #4 is silly because are for our protection in galus. The Rambam, who the “MO” hold of, warned the Yemenite Jews in Iggeres Teiman to not rebel against their gentile oppressors BECAUSE OF the oaths EVEN THOUGH the gentiles were severely oppressing them.

That’s psak, not the fairy tales in which some here, R”L, make out the gemara in Kesubos to be. Your questions about why they don’t appear here or there are valid from an academic perspective. But they are indisputably halacha, as “RZ” take great pains – futilely, of course – to wish away their current applicability.

Zionism is heresy and idolatry and the Zionists have no mesorah and no answers for their foolishness.