Reply To: DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction?

Home Forums YWN Main Site & Coffee Room Issues DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction? Reply To: DATI LEUMI AND CHAREDI- why is there such friction?

#1112069
rabbiofberlin
Participant

To all those pointing to the “three oaths”: See gemoro Sottah 10A, top of the daf, which fully supports Avi K in what he wrote that, when one side does not respect the “shevuoh”, the “shevuoh-oath” is cancelled. Sam2 also pointed to it and I have just shown the source of this. Gemoro and rashi concur.

So, as the nations of the world have dealt with us in the most terrible way, the “sholosh shevuos”- even if accepted- are cancelled and should not be quoted as opposing the establishment of medinas yisroel.