“Of Star K and Shabbos Oven fame? Puk Chazi that the Gedolim in EY disagree with him.”
What a childish red-herring, even from you. This is a simple question of the definition of tzedaka and nowhere do the Gedolim of E”Y disagree. Regarding the ovens, Harav Heinemann, shlita, told people to listen to the Gedolim.
Get back to work, gavra.