newbee
“Im not sure what to say, I just dont find these things meaningful.”
I’m not sure why you dont find halachcly Jewish meaningful. Chazal say Af al pi shechatu Yisroel hu. Why would you disagree and say “He isnt Jewish” (in any meaningful way)?
“I dont put a big emphasis “
Nobody here is saying to put a big emphasis. Just acknowledge like Chazal do. That he is Jewish even if a sinner!
“Regarding other people in other countries having a Jewish neshama… I am not sure why that would bother you or others. “
Becasue it is counter factual and illogical.
The thing that bother me is that you dont even respond to questions.
Eg can you buy chametz from a Goy after Pesach? You never attempted to reply to this simple direct question on your position
Or better yet can you sell a goy your chametz (this would be de’oraysa if he was actually a yid)