Reply To: Should Yeshiva's (all of them) say Mishberach for Israel soldiers on Shabbos?

Home Forums Eretz Yisroel Should Yeshiva's (all of them) say Mishberach for Israel soldiers on Shabbos? Reply To: Should Yeshiva's (all of them) say Mishberach for Israel soldiers on Shabbos?

#1139756
☕ DaasYochid ☕
Participant

It shouldn’t be used as a sword to attack those who don’t say it by implying that they don’t appreciate what soldiers are risking and fighting for…

You do realize that this thread was likely started for that purpose (as was the other I linked to earlier)?

I’m sure many, probably most people who say it do it with pure intentions.

there is a difference between a fire which, while dangerous, is not actively seeking to kill and destroy as it is not a living conscious being. As opposed to our enemies who would like nothing more than to kill us

That’s actually very cynical, to say that the emotion is largely hatred for the enemy, rather than concern for our fellow Yidden’s safety. The better chillul to say would be that more soldiers are at risk and die than do firefighters. Of course that’s not the real reason it was instituted…