Sam2:
Well, HaKatan’s taking an off the cuff humorous comment in the middle of a Shiur as a way to make R’ Schachter seem like a fool constitutes an ad hominem attack, and something the mods certainly shouldn’t have let through.
Listen, I by no means agree with everything HaKatan has said. But I think to label that comment “an ad hominem attack” is simply not true.
If anything, HaKatan has been on the receiving end of most of the attacks here.
OURtorah:
MY bubby and zadie didn’t survive to see people like YOU exist.
That is an absolutely horrible thing to say. I don’t care how right you think you are, nothing justifies a comment like that. And this coming in the middle of a comment preaching about “LOVE,. LOVE. LOVE”, no less.
“Your words are hateful, and if you don’t see it that way, I AM TELLING YOU THEY R HURTFUL.”