Reply To: What's with the left wing and kitniyos

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee What's with the left wing and kitniyos Reply To: What's with the left wing and kitniyos

#1149183
charliehall
Participant

“Just because a grain has been (relatively) recently discovered does not mean that it can’t fall into a category, and hence a prohibition”

Except that with kitniyot there is no prohibition. It is a longstanding minhag.

(FWIW I absolutely oppose dropping that minhag unless one actually moves to a Sefardic community and adopts all Sefardic minhagim and halachic rulings.)

“Kitniyos are harvested and processed in the same way that chametz is. “

Not true for rice — almost all of it is grown in flooded fields. None of the harvesting equipment used for land based plants would work. Think Pharoah’s chariots in the Yam Suf.