Reply To: Hagbah (and Gelilla)

Home Forums Litoeles H'rabim! Hagbah (and Gelilla) Reply To: Hagbah (and Gelilla)

#1170675

I think he might just have been humorously using the formula of halachos such as those about drinking havdoloh wine during the 9 Days, and assuming people would realize not to take the answer seriously. (Really, now, “such is the minhag of the rabbonim and talmidei chachomim that they never do gelillah in such shuls?” In a shul where gelilah is customarily given to a child, it would be a bizayon to give it to an adam chashuv! So I don’t think his post is to be taken at face value.)