“You begin by quoting what a poseik told you, namely, “Hashem doesn’t want us to be depressed,” in a discussion about text messaging. Then you extrapolate from this statement what your Rav would say about eye shadow.”
You quote me completely incorrectly:
1. I never referred to him as a poseik.
2. I never said anything about what he would say about eye shadow.
What I said was that he would tell her to wear makeup. And yes, I do know that he would say that.