Health- Some of the Greatest people (Rosh Hayeshavas) smoked in previous generations. Are you saying that they too are sinners? There is a Gammarah in Chullin concerning the donkey of R’ Pincos Ben Yair, that G-d wouldn’t let it eat grain that wasn’t tithed because it was a sin, so surely G-d wouldn’t permit the Tzadick to sin. But you hold that these Saintly Rabbis who smoked are sinners, you are rewriting history.
Menu