The Jews aren’t committing the crimes, but crimes are committed against them. There are tons of mugging in Lakewood, and there would be more if people weren’t scared to walk around at night.
There have also been several attempted kidnappings and abductions, and at least one actual abduction.
There are far more muggings and attempted kidnappings in Lakewood than in Israel. And this is despite the fact that people are much more careful there than in EY. In Israel, people walk around late at night, and give their kids much more freedom, since kidnapping is not an issue.
Also, if you are only talking about Lakewood, then you shouldn’t be comparing it to the entire Israel – you should be comparing it to places like Beitar, Ramat Beit Shemesh and Kiryat Sefer. The crime rate is way lower in those places than in Lakewood!