Reply To: How many times did you say Sh’monah Esreh tonight?

I know this is old, but maybe someone can explain this to me.

First Bar Shattya wrote…

health-

sorry buddy, you’ve got either two or four. if you want to count v’sain bracha it works exactly the same as l’hoshia mechalkel. Personally i suggest we count them both seeing as you have to repeat shmoneh esray for the lack of either omission.

Then JustHold wrote…

BAR SHATTYA: you are tottally wrong here!

Then Bar Shattya responds…

justhold-

oh. oops. my bad.

I’m not seeing how bar shattya is wrong, though he seems to be admitting to a mistake when he says “oops. my bad”