Mistake #1) There is a difference between erring on the side of caution and pointing out problems with a post a moderator chooses to post.
Mistake #2) I guess in this specific case there wasn’t much more than what met the eye, because there was no evidence of any editing and the moderator was very clear about what s/he had against the post.
Are you worried about my comment on Rebshidduch’s shidduch history?
Is there anything else I was wrong about?
(BTW, You’ll notice that I didn’t write my post when you defended Shopping613; I wrote it after a Moderator hinted there may be more and you asked for explanation. It may make a difference to your list of fallacies)