2scents
the question is do they have a right to a personal preference
“everyone has their own personal preference. Some people prefer not to go to the hospital at all, or to call a cab. ”
I agree completely! that is precisely my point. and those who want a women only group should have that option too.
Granted this group should know their limitations, and perhaps may need to revamped. But in theroy at least, if soem women want a women only group for soem situations they shoudl have that.
Now some may say that even those who want a woman only group shouldnt have one. The reason for why they shoudlnt have one is a side issue tznius, women shouldnt be visible, women shouldnt be accomodated, women arent as good, we already have hatzola, it would be confusing and lead to mistakes, some of these may be valid concerns . but the bottom line is a simple question :
“should Women have the option of calling a women only group in some situations?
Period. yes or no?”
My question is not what YOU would prefer if you were a woman in such a situation. It is do you feel SOME WOMEN (not all) should have the opportunity (NOT BE FORCED) to call a woman only group