CT lawyer
I dont disagree with the gist of your point.
However a point that does deserve mention (whcih I assume is part of the argument) Is that the NYC Public schools sytem cant handle us.
Many are already struggling, and it isnt like they have a surplus of cash lying around. there are approximatly 100,000 kids in Yeshivas all of whom are entitled to education and who the system is nt read yto accommodate.
All the more so when you factor in Kosher food (which correct me if Im wrong, but the I believe the public schools would have to provide).
IT sint quite the same as swimming pools where if you dotn want to swim no problem. Kids must have an education, so We am being forced to pay for an education that the city knows full well we will not take nor can they provide if 100,000 of us where to say, ok public schools we are here.
DY
“Correct, the OP is asking for even less than I am”
It sint about more vs/ less its about making a case for your point. And given that a private school is a luxury I dotn why it shouldn’t be included in taxable income (which is not at all what you are arguing)